OverpayWise

Mortgage intelligence

Mortgage comparison tool

Compare two mortgage deals through the fix and beyond.

Enter the mortgage amount, fixed rate, fixed period, product fee, follow-on rate, and overpayment for each deal to compare cash paid and balance over time.

Quick read

Full-term winner

Mortgage B

£21,479 total cost difference over the modelled mortgage terms.

This estimate models one fixed-rate period followed by one follow-on rate. It does not include remortgaging, incentives, valuation costs, or early repayment charges.

Adviser report

Printable scenario summary

Build a print-friendly pack with the figures entered, main results, assumptions, caveats, and next discussion points. Nothing is saved and no PDF is generated on the server.

Estimate

Mortgage deal snapshot

Estimated better fit: Mortgage B

Mortgage B looks stronger on the modelled numbers.

Winner over initial fix
Mortgage A
£47,991 difference during the fix.
Winner over full term
Mortgage B
£21,479 total cost difference.
Monthly payment gap
£42
Difference during the fixed-rate period.
Lower balance after fix
Mortgage B
£20,145 balance difference.

Inputs

Mortgage details

Purchase context

These values help carry the selected mortgage into the dashboard. Edit them if your buying-cost check changed the deposit or property value.

LTV (loan-to-value)

80%

Based on Mortgage A mortgage amount and the property value.

Mortgage A
Mortgage B

Estimate

Side-by-side result

Estimated better fit

Mortgage B

Mortgage B looks stronger on the modelled numbers.

Winner over initial fix

Mortgage A

Lower amount paid by each fix end.

Winner over full term

Mortgage B

Lower total paid over the full mortgage.

Lower balance after fix

Mortgage B

Useful when deciding what happens next.

Monthly payment difference

£42

Total cost difference

£21,479

Cost during fix difference

£47,991

Remaining balance after fix difference

£20,145

Result interpretation

What the side-by-side comparison may suggest

What it means
This may suggest which mortgage has the lower modelled cost across the fixed period and across the full mortgage term entered.
Number that matters most
The most useful number depends on your horizon: monthly difference matters for cash flow, while total cost difference matters for the modelled full term.
Be careful about
The estimate assumes one fixed period and one follow-on rate. Future remortgaging, incentives, ERCs, affordability, and product rules can change the result.
Explore next
You may want to compare the period you expect to keep the deal, then check overpayment limits or speak to a mortgage adviser before choosing.

First-time buyer guide

How to compare deals without getting lost in the jargon

Lowest monthly payment is not always the cheapest mortgage. Use the monthly payment, fees, remaining balance, follow-on rate, LTV, and product rules together before treating one deal as better.

Fixed rate

The interest rate you pay for the initial deal period, such as 2 or 5 years.

Why this matters

It strongly affects the monthly payment while the fix lasts.

Common misunderstanding

A lower fixed rate can still cost more if fees, term, or balance after the fix are worse.

Mortgage term

The total time used to repay the mortgage, often 25 to 35 years for a first-time buyer.

Why this matters

A longer term can reduce monthly payments but usually increases total interest.

Common misunderstanding

Choosing the lowest monthly payment does not automatically mean choosing the cheapest mortgage.

Follow-on rate

The rate used after the fixed period ends if you do not remortgage or switch product.

Why this matters

It can change the comparison if one deal looks cheap during the fix but expensive afterwards.

Common misunderstanding

Many buyers compare only the fixed period and forget what happens after it ends.

Product fee

A lender fee for taking the mortgage product, paid upfront or added to the mortgage.

Why this matters

A low rate with a high fee may not beat a slightly higher rate with a lower fee.

Common misunderstanding

Adding the fee to the mortgage is not free; it can increase the balance and interest.

ERC

An early repayment charge may apply if you repay, overpay too much, or leave the deal early.

Why this matters

It can affect whether a deal is flexible enough if you sell, overpay, or remortgage early.

Common misunderstanding

This comparison does not model ERCs, so check the product rules separately.

LTV

Loan-to-value compares the mortgage amount with the property value.

Why this matters

LTV bands can affect which rates you qualify for and how much deposit is needed.

Common misunderstanding

A small change in deposit or property value can move the deal into a different LTV band.

Lowest monthly payment check

Lowest monthly payment is not always the cheapest mortgage because fees, rate changes, term length, and the balance left after the fix can move the true cost.

How to compare deals

  1. Start with the same property value, deposit, mortgage amount, and term for both deals unless you deliberately want to test a different scenario.
  2. Compare the fixed-period monthly payment, but also compare product fees and the balance after the fix.
  3. Look at the full-term estimate as a stress test, not a promise, because most buyers remortgage before the full term ends.
  4. Check lender eligibility, ERCs, overpayment rules, and whether the monthly payment still leaves a cash buffer.

Use these numbers next

Carry this estimate into the next step.

Use these Mortgage B figures as a planning snapshot if this is the scenario you want to visualise in the dashboard next.

Continue to plan ownership
Monthly payment
£1,347
Use this as the planned monthly mortgage payment while the initial rate applies.
Mortgage amount
£250,000
Use this as the planned mortgage amount in the ownership dashboard.
Product fee
£1,499
Keep this visible because paying upfront or adding it to the loan changes the comparison.
Remaining balance
£218,524
Use this to understand the possible balance when the initial deal period ends.

Confidence check

First-time buyer confidence checklist

Use this checklist to spot planning gaps before you move from calculator estimates to conversations with lenders, brokers, or conveyancers. This is educational only and is not financial advice.

  • Have you allowed for a cash buffer?

    Keep emergency savings separate from the deposit and completion costs before treating a purchase budget as comfortable.

    Review buying costs
  • Have you considered moving costs?

    Budget for removals, legal work, surveys, mortgage fees, insurance, utilities, and immediate setup costs after completion.

    Check upfront cost maths
  • Do you need an Agreement in Principle?

    An Agreement in Principle can help you understand whether a lender may consider your application before you make an offer.

    Plan your mortgage steps
  • Have you checked lender eligibility?

    Income, credit history, deposit source, employment type, property type, and existing commitments can all affect lender decisions.

    Understand affordability
  • Are your assumptions realistic?

    Sense-check the property value, deposit, mortgage amount, rate, fees, term, and monthly payment against current quotes before relying on the estimate.

    Review comparison assumptions

Assumptions

Mortgage A and B assumptions

Check these inputs before relying on the result.

Mortgage A mortgage amount
£250,000
4.5% for 2 years, then 6.5%.
Mortgage B mortgage amount
£250,000
4.2% for 5 years, then 6.5%.
Mortgage A term
25 years
Used to estimate the monthly repayment schedule.
Mortgage B term
25 years
Used to estimate the monthly repayment schedule.
Product fees
£999 vs £1,499
Fees are treated as either paid upfront or added to the mortgage, based on the selected option.
Monthly overpayments
£0 vs £0
Assumed to stay constant and reduce the relevant balance each month.

Last reviewed

12 June 2026

Interest method

Monthly interest is estimated from the annual rate unless a page states a different method. Lender figures can use daily interest, product-specific rules, and exact payment dates.

Educational scope

UK-focused calculator estimate. It explains trade-offs and does not make a personal recommendation.

How this is calculated
  1. The annual interest rate is converted into a monthly rate.
  2. Each month, interest is estimated on the current mortgage balance.
  3. The repayment first covers that month's interest. The rest reduces the balance.
  4. As the balance falls, less interest is charged and more of each payment goes towards the debt.

Learn the mortgage maths behind these estimates →

Main limitations
  • The estimate uses the values entered on this page and does not check lender eligibility, affordability, credit history, product availability, or personal tax treatment.
  • Fees, ERCs, insurance, valuation costs, legal costs, rate changes, and overpayment rules are included only where the calculator explicitly asks for them.
How the deal comparison is calculated
  1. Each deal is modelled as a repayment mortgage using its mortgage amount, term, fixed rate, and fee treatment.
  2. Payments during the fixed period use the fixed rate entered for that mortgage.
  3. After the fix, the calculator uses the follow-on rate entered for that mortgage.
  4. The comparison then checks monthly payments, fixed-period cost, balance after the fix, total interest, and total cost.

Results are estimates based on the assumptions shown here. They are not financial advice and can differ from lender figures because real products, fees, rate changes, overpayment rules, and repayment timing vary.

Learn the comparison maths

Understand why the lowest monthly payment may not be cheapest

Follow a plain-English lesson covering fixed rates, product fees, follow-on rates, total borrowing costs, and a worked two-mortgage comparison.

Open the comparison lesson

Recommendation summary

What the comparison suggests

Estimated better fit

Mortgage B

Mortgage B looks stronger on the modelled numbers.

During the fix

Mortgage A is lower

Difference: £47,991

Over the full term

Mortgage B is lower

Difference: £21,479

Monthly pressure

Mortgage B is lower

Difference: £42

Balance after fix

Mortgage B is lower

Difference: £20,145

The fixed-period winner and full-term winner differ. That usually means your remortgage plan matters: compare the period you expect to keep the deal, not only the headline monthly payment.

Mortgage A

Monthly during fix

£1,390

Cost during fix

£34,349

Balance after fix

£238,669

Total interest

£243,842

Mortgage B

Monthly during fix

£1,347

Cost during fix

£82,340

Balance after fix

£218,524

Total interest

£221,863

Visual comparison

Amount paid over time

The line charts compare cumulative amount paid and remaining balance at yearly intervals. The exact numbers are also summarised in the cards and table below.

Mortgage AMortgage B
Mortgage A total paid
£494,841
Mortgage B total paid
£473,362
Mortgage A balance after fix
£238,669
Mortgage B balance after fix
£218,524

Balance remaining over time

Lower balances can matter if you expect to remortgage, move, or make further overpayment decisions after the fixed period.

Monthly payment during fix

Remaining balance after fix

Compare

Mortgage A vs Mortgage B

Mortgage amount

Mortgage A
£250,000
Mortgage B
£250,000

Fixed rate

Mortgage A
4.5%
Mortgage B
4.2%

Fixed period

Mortgage A
2 years
Mortgage B
5 years

Rate after fix

Mortgage A
6.5%
Mortgage B
6.5%

Fee

Mortgage A
£999
Mortgage B
£1,499

Fee treatment

Mortgage A
Paid upfront
Mortgage B
Paid upfront

Term

Mortgage A
25 years
Mortgage B
25 years

Monthly overpayment

Mortgage A
£0
Mortgage B
£0

Monthly payment during fix

Mortgage A
£1,390
Mortgage B
£1,347

Monthly payment after fix

Mortgage A
£1,668
Mortgage B
£1,629

Cost during fix

Mortgage A
£34,349
Mortgage B
£82,340

Remaining balance after fix

Mortgage A
£238,669
Mortgage B
£218,524

Total interest

Mortgage A
£243,842
Mortgage B
£221,863

Total cost

Mortgage A
£494,841
Mortgage B
£473,362

Recommended next steps

What to check next

A short follow-up can help put this estimate into context before you make a money decision.

Important disclaimer

This calculator provides estimates only and does not constitute mortgage or financial advice. It assumes repayment mortgages, one fixed-rate period, one follow-on rate, and constant overpayments. Your lender offer may include other costs, incentives, early repayment charges, or restrictions.

Learn This Calculation

Understand the lesson behind Mortgage Comparison Tool.

Use the education page before relying on the result. It explains the assumptions, shows the maths, gives worked examples, and includes practice questions so the estimate is easier to check.

Tutorial

Learn why the lowest monthly payment is not always the lowest-cost mortgage.

Maths lesson

Covers fixed-rate payments, product fees, balances after a fix, follow-on rates, and total modelled cost.

Worked examples

Works through two deals with different fees and follow-on rates to expose the trade-off.

Practice questions

Practise comparing two deals over the fixed period and across the full term.

Next Lesson

Check remortgage break-even

If you already have a mortgage, compare staying put with switching after fees and ERCs.